• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

The Kitchen Prep Blog

Easy Recipes with a Fresh Twist

  • Home
  • About Dianna
  • Recipe Index
  • Work With Me
    • Disclosure Policy
  • Contact
menu icon
go to homepage
subscribe
search icon
Homepage link
  • Home
  • Recipe Index
  • About Dianna
  • Work With Me
  • Contact
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter
  • ×
    Home » Cookies

    Pumpkin Butter Thumbprint Cookies

    Published: Sep 29, 2014 · Modified: Jun 3, 2020 by thekitchenprep · This post may contain affiliate links ·

    Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

    Pumpkin Butter Thumbprint Cookies! The ultimate fall cookies, these sweet treats are rolled in crunchy toasted pecans and filled with a delicious spiced store-bought pumpkin butter. A great cookie to make for fall holidays! 

    Pumpkin Butter Thumbprint Cookies! The ultimate fall cookies, these sweet treats are rolled in crunchy toasted pecans and filled with a delicious spiced store-bought pumpkin butter. A great cookie to make for fall holidays! 
    Disclsoure: This post may contain affiliate links, which means I may receive a commission if you click a link and purchase something that I've recommended. Clicking these links won't cost you any extra money, but the small commission I earn on each purchase will go towards the costs of running this blog! Thanks!

    My First Visit To Trader Joe's

    You guys. My life has been changed forever.

    They {finally} built a Trader Joe's within a decent distance of where I live. It opened 2 days before my birthday. I'm fairly certain they planned that out that as a gift to me. Thank you to all those who came together to make it happen.

    As the sun rose last Sunday and I opened my eyes on the first day of my 33rd year on this planet, my sweet husband wished me a happy birthday. I cleared my throat and responded, "Can we get to Trader Joe's before it get's packed?" Signs you're getting old.

    Because Steve is so good to me and wouldn't dream of shattering my birthday plans, we were up, dressed and wandering the aisles of TJ's by 8:15 a.m. It was magical.

    I may be over-exaggerating a tiny bit. {But not by much.} I mean, it's a grocery store, not one of the wonders of the world. {Though I warn you, do not argue this point with anyone who is a huge fan. You will lose.} However, I can tell you that as we stood there with our mouths agape staring at a wall of reasonably priced, {organic!!!} packaged greens of every possible combination you can think of, we knew we had stumbled onto something special. I even heard Steve mumble, "Is this for real?"

    It is real, my dear, and it is glorious.

    Now, navigating TJ's as a "first-timer" can be a tricky feat. Because you'll want to buy all the things. I'm talking stuff you have no need for and hardly ever eat. "But it's only $1.99!", you'll rationalize.

    PUT DOWN THE CHILI-LIME ROASTED ALMONDS AND WALK AWAY. No, do not stop to look at the multitude of nut butters {or cookie butter, for that matter. There is no nutritional value in cookie butter even if it's housed right next to the chia and flax peanut butter.} that are suddenly available to you. You came for almond butter... now, put the almond butter in your basket and back away slowly.

    Ok, so I may not have left completely unscathed. It was my first visit, and my birthday for heaven's sake, cut me some slack. I splurged on a small jar of pumpkin butter because it was there and fall was officially beginning that week. So, clearly it was a necessity.

    Then, as penance, I came home and decided to use the pumpkin butter in a recipe for fall cookies to share with you. Because I'm considerate that way and because otherwise I may have simply eaten it by the spoonful.

    Pumpkin Butter Thumbprint Cookies! The ultimate fall cookies, these sweet treats are rolled in crunchy toasted pecans and filled with a delicious spiced store-bought pumpkin butter. A great cookie to make for fall holidays! 

    What is Pumpkin Butter?

    Pumpkin Butter, incidentally, has very little to do with butter, except that it's rich and creamy like its namesake. It's actually a sweet, jam-like spread infused with pumpkin spice-type flavors. Like apple butter, except pumpkin-y!

    What are other uses for pumpkin butter, you might ask? You can spread on muffins, pancakes, waffles, drizzle over ice cream or oatmeal, or use as a pastry filling. I even used it in a savory application in these Pumpkin Butter Turkey & Cheese Sliders!

    Pumpkin Butter Thumbprint Cookies

    Is there anything that brings greater feelings of nostalgia than a thumbprint cookie? The flavors in these sweet treats make them the ultimate fall cookies!

    For the cookie portion of these, I used a cream cheese-based dough that I adapted from Allie's recipe {Baking a Moment} to make them a bit sturdier, and rolled them in toasted pecan bits for some crunch. Then, I filled the centers with Trader Joe's Pumpkin Butter. You will not be sorry that you sacrificed some of your beloved Pumpkin Butter for these babies.

    The way you make the imprint in your thumbprint cookie is up to you. You can use your thumb if you'd really like to, but I prefer using the back of a teaspoon measuring spoon to make a perfectly round little well in the center of each cookie. You can keep it from sticking by dipping it in a bit of flour before you create each well, or by spraying the rounded part of the teaspoon with a little cooking spray every few times you make an indentation.

    Pumpkin Butter Thumbprint Cookies! The ultimate fall cookies, these sweet treats are rolled in crunchy toasted pecans and filled with a delicious spiced store-bought pumpkin butter. A great cookie to make for fall holidays! 

    Tips for Making Thumbprint Cookies

    Thumbprint cookies are generally an easy cookie to make, but there are a few tips that you should follow to achieve thumbprint success:

    • Try to get the dough balls as even in size as possible to ensure that they all bake at the same rate. You can use a cookie scoop to get approximately the same size dough each time, or for more precise measuring, you can use a kitchen scale.
    • The cream cheese-based dough is soft when it's first made, so chilling for about an hour will help the cookies to hold their shape as they bake.
    • The cookies will remain soft when they're warm, so let them cool for at least 10 minutes if not longer before moving them to a cooling rack or lifting them.
    Pumpkin Butter Thumbprint Cookies! The ultimate fall cookies, these sweet treats are rolled in crunchy toasted pecans and filled with a delicious spiced store-bought pumpkin butter. A great cookie to make for fall holidays! 

    Note: I also made a version of these without nuts and they were very tasty, too! They do spread a little further, so take that into account when placing onto the baking pan.

    Pumpkin Butter Thumbprint Cookies! The ultimate fall cookies, these sweet treats are rolled in crunchy toasted pecans and filled with a delicious spiced store-bought pumpkin butter. A great cookie to make for fall holidays! 
    Love thumbprint cookies? Here are a few others I've made that you might enjoy as well! 
    • Raspberry Cheesecake Chocolate Thumbprint Cookies
    • Peppermint Mocha Truffle Thumbprint Cookies
    So, tell me, do you have a Trader Joe's near you? Have you found yourself doing the dance of the conflicted grocery shopper in their kitschy aisles? Go ahead, divulge what your TJ's splurges are... make me feel better! 😉

    Pumpkin Butter Thumbprint Cookies

    Dianna Muscari | The Kitchen Prep
    Pumpkin Butter Thumbprint Cookies! The ultimate fall cookies, these sweet treats are rolled in crunchy toasted pecans and filled with a delicious spiced store-bought pumpkin butter. A great cookie to make for fall holidays! 
    Print Recipe Pin Recipe
    Prep Time 1 hour hr 20 minutes mins
    Cook Time 14 minutes mins
    Total Time 1 hour hr 34 minutes mins
    Course Dessert
    Cuisine American
    Servings 24 cookies, depending on size

    Ingredients
      

    • 8 tablespoons butter softened
    • 3 ounces cream cheese softened
    • ½ cup granulated sugar
    • ½ teaspoon vanilla extract
    • ¼ teaspoon sea salt
    • 1¼ cups all-purpose flour
    • 1 egg beaten
    • 1 tablespoon water
    • ⅓ cup pecan bits
    • ⅓ cup pumpkin butter

    Instructions
     

    • Preheat oven to 350° degrees. Prepare a baking pan by lining with a silicone baking mat or parchment paper.
    • In the bowl of a stand mixer, beat together butter, cream cheese, sugar, vanilla extract and salt until smooth.
    • Slowly add in the flour and mix until just incorporated. If the dough is too soft to handle, refrigerate for 30 minutes to 1 hour or until it is easier to handle.
    • Beat egg and water in a small bowl. In another bowl, place pecan bits for rolling. Set aside.
    • Scoop about a tablespoonful of dough and roll it into a ball. Dredge each ball in the egg wash; drop into the pecans and roll around to coat.
    • Place onto the prepared pan. Continue until all the dough is used up.
    • Using a teaspoon measure or your thumb, push down on the top of each dough ball to create an indentation.
    • Fill each well with a heaping ½ teaspoon of Pumpkin Butter until just filled.
    • Bake for about 12-14 minutes or until the edges and bottoms are just starting to brown and the cookies are set.
    • Remove from oven and allow to cool for 10-15 minutes before moving the cookies to a cooling rack as they will be soft and more difficult to move when warm.

    Notes

    Cookie dough adapted from Baking a Moment

    More Cookies

    • A variety of No Spread Sugar Cookies on a cooling rack, with one being lifted by a cookie spatula.
      No Spread Sugar Cookies
    • Chocolate Covered Graham Crackers piled on top of each other on a marble background.
      Chocolate Covered Graham Crackers
    • A collage of chocolate chip cookies being baked in an air fryer.
      How to Bake Cookies in the Air Fryer
    • Raspberry Cheesecake Thumbprint Cookies on a white plate with holiday ornament in background.
      Raspberry Cheesecake Chocolate Thumbprint Cookies

    Reader Interactions

    Comments

    1. bmayer says

      September 29, 2014 at 2:20 pm

      Their ginger snaps are more "chewy" than "snappy", but oh so delicious. I love their dark chocolate covered almonds, and I bought the Organic Tomato Roasted Red Pepper Soup but I havent tried it yet. I also bought the Orange Muscat Champagne Vinegar, just because, how often do you see Orange Muscat Champagne vinegar?.....but I have no idea what to do with it. Got any ideas?

      Reply
    2. Alyson says

      September 29, 2014 at 7:49 pm

      YUM! These look delicious, and I pretty much love everything inside the store. It's kind of a problem. Maybe we should lunch date there sometime? 🙂 #dangerous

      alyson
      http://www.theaveragegirlsguide.com

      Reply
    3. Meagan Brockway says

      October 01, 2014 at 9:56 am

      Peanut butter cups! You must get the peanut butter cups!

      Reply
    4. Karis says

      October 01, 2014 at 4:30 pm

      So happy to hear you finally got a Trader Joe's near you! When we lived in Wisconsin we shopped weekly at TJ's and I had a long list of staples I purchased from there. After moving to South Florida, I went into withdrawal. One year later a TJ's is opening about 30 minutes from my apartment and I will be there on October 10th when they open!

      Reply
    5. Chineka @ Savor The Baking says

      October 06, 2014 at 2:31 am

      I've heard about the different "butters" at Trader Joe's, but have yet to try them. This seems like a good way to try one of their butters and incorporate it into a recipe for the Fall.

      Reply

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Recipe Rating




    Primary Sidebar

    Hi! I'm Dianna. I used to think cooking had to be complicated to be good, so I never considered it "my thing." Now I know that's far from true, and my mission is to create & share easy, mouthwatering recipes - from weeknight dinners to simple bites for entertaining - that anyone can make! Join me in my South Florida kitchen and let's get cooking!

    More about me →

    Popular

    • Fork and knife cutting into a stuffed cubanelle pepper.
      Stuffed Cubanelle Peppers

    • Benedictine Spread for Kentucky Derby in a white bowl with a piece of pumpernickel toast in the foreground slathered with spread.
      Benedictine Spread - A Derby Classic

    • Close up of Italian Knot Cookies on a white cake plate.
      Italian Knot Cookies

    • A large skillet filled with Creamy Mushroom & Chicken Sausage Florentine Pasta with a yellow and white striped dish towel underneath.
      Creamy Mushroom & Chicken Sausage Florentine Pasta

    Welcome!

    I'm Dianna and I've been creating & sharing easy recipes with a fresh twist for 14 years!

    More about me

    Popular

    • A large skillet filled with Creamy Mushroom & Chicken Sausage Florentine Pasta with a yellow and white striped dish towel underneath.
      Creamy Mushroom & Chicken Sausage Florentine Pasta
    • Moroccan-Spiced Vegetable Soup via The Kitchen Prep. An easy and flavorful meal for a cold day!
      Moroccan-Spiced Vegetable Soup with Couscous
    • Irish Cheddar & Cabbage Hash Brown Skillet on a dark green surface with a striped kitchen towel beside it.
      Irish Cheddar & Cabbage Hash Brown Skillet
    • A pavlova nest with coconut custard filling sprinkled with coconut flakes and drizzled with chocolate.
      Mini Pavlova Nests

    Seasonal

    • Orange-Avocado Salad
      Orange-Avocado Salad with Honey Vinaigrette
    • Sausage & Squash Soup in a white mug with ingredients around it.
      Sausage & Squash Soup
    • A stack of sweet corn and black bean fritters in a mini cast iron skillet with fresh sweet corn in the background.
      Sweet Corn & Black Bean Fritters
    • Vanilla Bean Citrus Bars! A crisp, shortbread crust is topped with a layer of sweet, citrusy filling speckled with fragrant vanilla beans. These are the stuff of potluck dreams!
      Vanilla Bean Citrus Bars
    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • RSS
    • Twitter

    Follow Me on Facebook

    Welcome!

    I'm Dianna and I've been creating & sharing easy recipes with a fresh twist for 14 years!

    More about me

    Popular

    • A large skillet filled with Creamy Mushroom & Chicken Sausage Florentine Pasta with a yellow and white striped dish towel underneath.
      Creamy Mushroom & Chicken Sausage Florentine Pasta
    • Moroccan-Spiced Vegetable Soup via The Kitchen Prep. An easy and flavorful meal for a cold day!
      Moroccan-Spiced Vegetable Soup with Couscous
    • Irish Cheddar & Cabbage Hash Brown Skillet on a dark green surface with a striped kitchen towel beside it.
      Irish Cheddar & Cabbage Hash Brown Skillet
    • A pavlova nest with coconut custard filling sprinkled with coconut flakes and drizzled with chocolate.
      Mini Pavlova Nests

    Seasonal

    • Orange-Avocado Salad
      Orange-Avocado Salad with Honey Vinaigrette
    • Sausage & Squash Soup in a white mug with ingredients around it.
      Sausage & Squash Soup
    • A stack of sweet corn and black bean fritters in a mini cast iron skillet with fresh sweet corn in the background.
      Sweet Corn & Black Bean Fritters
    • Vanilla Bean Citrus Bars! A crisp, shortbread crust is topped with a layer of sweet, citrusy filling speckled with fragrant vanilla beans. These are the stuff of potluck dreams!
      Vanilla Bean Citrus Bars

    Footer

    ↑ back to top

    About

    • Privacy Policy
    • Disclosure Policy

    Subscribe

    • Sign Up! and get recipes delivered to your inbox.

    Contact

    • Contact
    • Work with Me

    Copyright © 2025 · The Kitchen Prep ·